Luke Bryan can now say he’s sold out Madison Square Garden not once, but twice. Fans snapped up all the seats for his January 25 show in five minutes, and when tickets for the second show went on sale Saturday morning, they too were gone in a couple minutes.

“I can’t thank my fans enough for being so eager to see us play in New York City,” Luke says. “I’m trying to let it all sink in but I cannot wait to get there and share my live show with them!”

Luke’s That’s My Kind of Night tour kicks off January 16 in Columbus, Ohio with Lee Brice and Cole Swindell. The second Madison Square Garden show won’t be until September 12.

This Sunday, Luke performs live on the American Music Awards at 8 p.m. ET on ABC.